Baseball Hall of Fame Class of 1958

<--1957

1959-->

Hall of Famer

Category

Inducted By

Yes %

---

Nominees who didn't make the cut in 1958

In 1958, there were 266 ballots cast by the voters, and a nominee needed 200 yes votes to reach the 75% threshold for induction. A minimum of 14 votes were required to remain on the ballot for the following year.

Nominee	Votes	Yes %
Max Carey	136	51.13%
Edd Roush	112	42.11%
Red Ruffing	99	37.22%
Hack Wilson	94	35.34%
Kiki Cuyler	90	33.83%
Sam Rice	90	33.83%
Tony Lazzeri	80	30.08%
Luke Appling	77	28.95%
Lefty Gomez	76	28.57%
Burleigh Grimes	71	26.69%
Red Faber	68	25.56%
Lou Boudreau	64	24.06%
Jim Bottomley	57	21.43%
Joe Medwick	50	18.8%
Pepper Martin	46	17.29%
Hank Gowdy	45	16.92%
Bucky Harris	45	16.92%
Dave Bancroft	43	16.17%
Lloyd Waner	39	14.66%
Waite Hoyt	37	13.91%
Chuck Klein	36	13.53%
Johnny Vander Meer	35	13.16%
Earle Combs	34	12.78%
Stan Coveleski	34	12.78%
Al Lopez	34	12.78%
Bucky Walters	33	12.41%
Eppa Rixey	32	12.03%
Leo Durocher	28	10.53%
Lefty O'Doul	27	10.15%
Jimmy Dykes	26	9.77%
Goose Goslin	26	9.77%
Charlie Grimm	26	9.77%
Bobby Doerr	25	9.4%
Jesse Haines	22	8.27%
Heinie Manush	22	8.27%
Nick Altrock	20	7.52%
Billy Southworth	18	6.77%
Freddie Fitzsimmons	16	6.02%
Paul Derringer	15	5.64%
Dolf Luque	15	5.64%
Earl Averill	14	5.26%
Babe Herman	13	4.89%
Art Nehf	13	4.89%
Red Rolfe	13	4.89%
Chick Hafey	12	4.51%
Terry Moore	12	4.51%
Schoolboy Rowe	12	4.51%
Tommy Bridges	11	4.14%
Joe Gordon	11	4.14%
Tommy Henrich	11	4.14%
Travis Jackson	11	4.14%
Steve O'Neill	10	3.76%
Muddy Ruel	10	3.76%
Wes Ferrell	9	3.38%
Joe Judge	9	3.38%
Charlie Keller	9	3.38%
Jack Quinn	9	3.38%
Wally Schang	8	3.01%
Birdie Tebbetts	8	3.01%
Glenn Wright	8	3.01%
Howard Ehmke	7	2.63%
Billy Herman	7	2.63%
Eddie Rommel	7	2.63%
Stan Hack	6	2.26%
Mel Harder	6	2.26%
Pinky Higgins	6	2.26%
Carl Mays	6	2.26%
Pete Reiser	6	2.26%
Charlie Root	6	2.26%
Arky Vaughan	6	2.26%
Cy Williams	6	2.26%
Bullet Joe Bush	5	1.88%
Frankie Crosetti	5	1.88%
Joe Dugan	5	1.88%
Orval Grove	5	1.88%
Fielder Jones	5	1.88%
Freddie Lindstrom	5	1.88%
Firpo Marberry	5	1.88%
Bob Meusel	5	1.88%
Moe Berg	4	1.5%
Max Bishop	4	1.5%
Dolph Camilli	4	1.5%
Cookie Lavagetto	4	1.5%
Ernie Lombardi	4	1.5%
Urban Shocker	4	1.5%
George Uhle	4	1.5%
Charlie Berry	3	1.13%
Mort Cooper	3	1.13%
Tony Cuccinello	3	1.13%
Bill Doak	3	1.13%
Lew Fonseca	3	1.13%
Mike Gonzalez	3	1.13%
Frankie Gustine	3	1.13%
Willie Kamm	3	1.13%
Bob O'Farrell	3	1.13%
Luke Sewell	3	1.13%
Billy Werber	3	1.13%
Jimmie Wilson	3	1.13%
Wally Berger	2	0.75%
Ossie Bluege	2	0.75%
Doc Cramer	2	0.75%
Tommy Holmes	2	0.75%
High Pockets Kelly	2	0.75%
Ray Kremer	2	0.75%
Freddy Leach	2	0.75%
Joe McCarthy	2	0.75%
Marty McManus	2	0.75%
Lee Meadows	2	0.75%
Van Mungo	2	0.75%
Cy Perkins	2	0.75%
Bill Sherdel	2	0.75%
Lon Warneke	2	0.75%
Earl Whitehill	2	0.75%
Sparky Adams	1	0.38%
Jimmy Austin	1	0.38%
Dick Bartell	1	0.38%
Larry Benton	1	0.38%
Ray Blades	1	0.38%
George Case	1	0.38%
Sam Chapman	1	0.38%
General Crowder	1	0.38%
Harry Danning	1	0.38%
Curt Davis	1	0.38%
Jumbo Elliott	1	0.38%
Rick Ferrell	1	0.38%
George Grantham	1	0.38%
Mule Haas	1	0.38%
Bill Hallahan	1	0.38%
Bubbles Hargrave	1	0.38%
Billy Jurges	1	0.38%
Ken Keltner	1	0.38%
Red Kress	1	0.38%
Red Lucas	1	0.38%
Gus Mancuso	1	0.38%
Bing Miller	1	0.38%
Wally Moses	1	0.38%
Johnny Mostil	1	0.38%
Charley O'Leary	1	0.38%
Monte Pearson	1	0.38%
Wally Pipp	1	0.38%
Hal Schumacher	1	0.38%
Jack Scott	1	0.38%
Joe Sewell	1	0.38%
Rip Sewell	1	0.38%
Warren Spahn	1	0.38%
Riggs Stephenson	1	0.38%
Gus Suhr	1	0.38%
Clyde Sukeforth	1	0.38%
Rube Walberg	1	0.38%
Harry Walker	1	0.38%
Ken Williams	1	0.38%
Whit Wyatt	1	0.38%
Pep Young	1	0.38%
Tom Zachary	1	0.38%

<--1957

1959-->